
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner
Teaching the Civil Rights Movement requires us to tell the full story of the American Experiment, replete with triumphs, tragedies, and the perpetual effort to realize the justice to which our founding documents aspire. The Declaration of Independence asserts two non-negotiable principles at the core of legitimate republics: governments exist to secure the equal unalienable rights of all people, and their authority to do so can only be derived from the consent of the governed. But the Founders also recognized the imperfection of human nature, which made constitutional guardrails necessary to restrain both our leaders and the people from abusing power. While these ideals made Emancipation possible, human imperfection helps explain why our Nation took eighty-nine years to move from the Fourth of July to Juneteenth.
One hundred years after the Emancipation Proclamation, Martin Luther King, Jr.’s “I Have a Dream” speech at the March on Washington reminded the nation that Black Americans “still languished in the corners of American society.” Months earlier, his “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” had argued that segregation laws were unjustly “inflicted on a minority that, as a result of being denied the right to vote, had no part in enacting or devising the law.” These laws, which King called the “manacles of segregation and the chains of discrimination” suffered a double illegitimacy: they were imposed without consent, and they denied Black Americans the very rights that government exists to secure.
In Federalist #39, James Madison underscores the necessity of serving the proper goal of government (the equal protection of unalienable rights), through legitimate processes (consent) and with accountability (limited tenure in office). A republic “derives all its powers directly or indirectly from the great body of the people…not from an inconsiderable proportion, or a favored class of it.” Otherwise, “a handful of tyrannical nobles” could tyrannize the public. Yet consent alone does not ensure legitimacy. Republics must be “administered by persons holding their offices during pleasure, for a limited period, or during good behavior.” Consent of the governed thus ensures the people’s authority to both select their lawmakers and hold these representatives accountable through regular elections.
The Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965 eventually moved the country closer to Madison’s republican vision by increasing access to the ballot and ending legal segregation in public accommodations and federally-funded programs. Ironically, these landmark laws, which extended the power of consent, have increasingly been altered by executive orders and informal bureaucratic guidance, a process that requires little accountability to the people. The problem is not the merits of any particular guidance or order, which reasonable citizens may support or oppose, but the process by which they are made.
Civil rights statutes often employ vague language or broad terminology, so their practical meaning is frequently determined after enactment. Ideally, the branch most accountable to the people, Congress, would clarify the scope and meaning of the law. However, the Civil Rights Act’s prohibition of discrimination in federally-funded programs (Title VI) and its ban on discrimination in employment (Title VII) have been reshaped by bureaucratic action and executive orders. President Johnson’s Executive Order 11246 (1965), for example, mandated that federal contractors “take affirmative action” in hiring, which went far beyond congressional requirements. Because Congress never enacted it, the order was revoked nearly sixty years later as easily as it was imposed, by President Trump’s Executive Order 14173 in January 2025.
Similarly, Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, a thirty-seven-word provision modeled on Title VI, has been transformed to cover everything from college athletics to the handling of sexual misconduct, almost entirely through informal letters or guidance written by unelected bureaucrats in the Department of Education. The Obama administration’s 2011 “Dear Colleague” Letter (DCL) effectively mandated parallel justice systems on campus to adjudicate allegations of peer sexual misconduct. The first Trump administration rescinded that DCL in 2017 and replaced it with a formal regulation in 2020. The Biden administration then replaced that regulation with its own rule in 2024, which a federal district court struck down in January 2025.
Regardless of one’s personal views of Executive Order 11246’s affirmative action requirements, the 2011 DCL, or the rules that followed it, policymaking through informal guidance or executive orders stands several layers of accountability removed from the Madisonian vision. Such mandates lack genuine consent of the governed because they are issued without a vote by Congress, are rarely publicly debated, and are often written by officials who never answer to voters. Moreover, what one administration imposes without Congress, the next can undo as easily. This mutability is itself harmful. As Madison warns in Federalist #62, it “poisons the blessing of liberty itself,” and breeds a “diminution of attachment and reverence” towards our constitutional system. Nowhere is this damage greater than with civil rights laws because rights that change with each administration are not secure at all. A policy enacted without consent can also be eliminated without consent. Restoring the concern for consent of the governed that animated the Civil Rights Era begins with insisting that our civil rights laws be made by Congress, not strokes of a pen.

Dr. Elizabeth Kaufer Busch is the Pete and Laura Walker Professor of American Studies and the Director of American Studies at Christopher Newport University.
Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.
Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.



Dr. Elizabeth Kaufer Busch is the Pete and Laura Walker Professor of American Studies and the Director of American Studies at Christopher Newport University.