Guest Essayist: John Bicknell

Our Commissioners | Office of the Texas Governor | Greg Abbott
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner

 

Henry Cabot Lodge was a Boston Brahmin, considered something of a snob even in Brahmin society, where social snobbery was raised to a high art. He had a distinguished academic and literary career. A graduate of Harvard Law School and one of the first men awarded a Ph.D. in history and government at Harvard, he was editor of the prestigious North American Review in the 1870s and a lecturer in history at his alma mater. 

 As his resume indicated, Lodge was not a man of the people. But he entered politics in 1880 and, after a few early bumps, served in Congress for the last 37 years of his life.

When President Woodrow Wilson attempted to take the United States into the League of Nations as part of the Versailles Treaty ending World War I, Lodge opposed the treaty. He rested his argument against the treaty on defending the right of the American people, through their representatives in Congress, to determine questions of war and peace rather than an international organization.

Lodge, who had at first supported the idea of a League of Nations, represented the middle of the Republican Party. To his left were members who supported U.S. membership. To his right were true isolationists. Lodge was no isolationist. His preference was for a league of democracies in which the United States could be an active partner in hemming in Germany while remaking the map of Europe to promote democratic values. He was willing to accept American membership in a League of Nations—just not the one on which President Woodrow Wilson insisted.

 The core of Lodge’s objections rested on Article X of the Versailles Treaty’s requirement to “guarantee the territorial integrity and the political independence of every member of the league.” Lodge argued that this guarantee took the power to decide questions of war and peace out of the hands of Congress and the American people and placed it with an international organization. Either the U.S. would be pulled into interminable wars, or it would leave the country in the position of failing to do something it had agreed by treaty to do. Neither was acceptable to Lodge.

As the debate began in late 1918, most Americans looked favorably on the League of Nations. Anything that promised “eternal preservation of the world’s peace,” as Lodge put it, looked good after the Great War. That, Lodge believed, was their first thought. He saw his task as educating the people about the dangers the League of Nations posed to American sovereignty, so their second thought would be something else.

In his initial Senate speech on the treaty, Lodge argued that Americans were being asked “to give up in part our sovereignty and independence and subject our will to the will of other nations.” He asked for time to consider a question of such importance. As Senate majority leader and chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, he had the authority to provide that time.

He warned against abandoning George Washington’s advice against “entangling alliances,” and said the League would spell the end of the Monroe Doctrine, the essence of which was that “American questions shall be settled by Americans alone.” 

Under the provisions of the treaty, the League of Nations itself would interpret the meaning of Article X. For Lodge, this was untenable. Interpretation of clauses that affected the United States, he argued, should be left “to the only people who can interpret it, the people of the United States.” 

Wilson posited that Article X in the Treaty of Versailles created a moral responsibility for the United States to respond militarily when the League called for it, but not a legal one. For Lodge, as well as some League supporters, that was a distinction without meaning. “All international obligations are moral ones,” one pro-treaty senator said. Lodge could not imagine the United States failing to live up to a moral obligation, legal or otherwise. 

 The Foreign Relations Committee sent the Treaty of Versailles to the Senate floor with recommendations for four reservations and amendments. The most important reservation was on Article X that said “the United States assumes no obligation to preserve the territorial integrity or independence of any other country or to interfere in controversies between nations – whether members of the league or not – under the provisions of Article 10, or to employ the military or naval forces of the United States under any article of the treaty for any purpose” unless Congress acts to declare war.The Republicans were split over the treaty and the reservations. Therefore, some of the moderate Republicans joined with Democrats on the floor to defeat the treaty with the amendments.

Wilson had earlier insisted that votes by the league on military responses were merely advisory. Now, though, he contradicted his earlier assurances, calling the reservation “a rejection of the covenant.” And indeed it was. “From the beginning there was no doubt that a majority of the Senate would not accept Article X as it stood,” Lodge wrote. Wilson refused to negotiate any changes, and the Senate voted down the Treaty of Versailles again.

Defeat of the Treaty of Versailles lay at the feet of Woodrow Wilson, who refused to negotiate, compromise, or even listen to the objections of senators or the American people.

 Lodge listened to the people while leading them. In doing so, he not only preserved American sovereignty, he helped the American people practice it.

 

John Bicknell was a journalist for 30 years as a reporter, editor, columnist, and opinion writer in Florida and Washington, D.C. He is the author of three books – The Pathfinder and the President: John C. Fremont, Abraham Lincoln, and the Battle for Emancipation; Lincoln’s Pathfinder: John C. Fremont and the Violent Election of 1856; and America 1844: Religious Fervor, Westward Expansion, and the Presidential Election That Transformed the Nation – and was a senior editor of the 2016, 2018, 2020, and 2022 editions of The Almanac of American Politics. He lives in Moweaqua, Illinois.

Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.

Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.

Guest Essayist: John Bicknell

Our Commissioners | Office of the Texas Governor | Greg Abbott
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner

The essays in our study reference the following edition of Democracy In America: University of Chicago Press – 1st edition translated by Harvey Mansfield and Delba Winthrop. Today’s essay references pages 493-495 of this edition of Democracy in America.

Modern readers who turn to any number of media options other than newspapers might find De Tocqueville’s focus on print to be archaic. But his thesis remains valid today when applied to those alternative forms of news and information gathering.

“Only a newspaper can come to deposit the same thought in a thousand minds at the same moment,” he wrote in the 1830s.

He wrote at the very moment when newspapers were beginning to boom, and just before the revolution in communication and transportation that accompanied the invention of the telegraph and the spread of railroads.

De Tocqueville tied the importance of newspapers in developing and fostering associations to his work’s main focus, the centrality of civil society to American culture.

Where groups of ordinary but active citizens matter more than elites, their ability to communicate with each other – in dependable forums with regular publication and an agreed upon idiom – was essential.

For him, this was not simply a matter of politics – of being a critical voice in defending the freedoms guaranteed by the Constitution. Newspapers, De Tocqueville asserted, “maintain civilization.”

In the classic construction, newspapers have never been very good at telling people what to think, but have been quite successful in telling people what to think about. “If there were no newspapers,” he wrote, “there would almost never be common action.”

In the 1830s – and, indeed, until the birth of the Yellow Press in the latter half of the 19th century — newspapers were typically party organs.

Again, De Tocqueville was writing at an opportune time, just as the Second Party System featuring the Jacksonian Democrats and the Whigs was forming. Newspapers chose sides and reported the news from the point of view of their sponsor party. (One could argue that we have come full circle on that account, with blatantly partisan media choosing sides rather than straining to maintain objectivity.)

What differentiated the United States from the aristocratic countries of Europe was the level of participation in public affairs by the common man. “The principal citizens who live in an aristocratic country perceive each other from afar,” he wrote, “and if they want to unite their forces, they move toward one another carrying a long a multitude in their train.”

Not so in America. Common people, “all being very small and lost in the crowd,” do not all know or know of each other as the elites usually do. They have to seek each other out. The avenue for doing so was the newspaper.

Today, that purpose is often better served by social media than by newspapers or television news. But the process described by De Tocqueville almost 200 years ago remains much the same, even as the medium has changed.

“Up comes a newspaper that exposes to their view the sentiment or the idea that had been presented to each of them simultaneously but separately,” he wrote. “All are immediately directed toward that light, and those wandering spirits who had long sought each other in the shadows finally meet each other and unite.” It is perhaps a romanticized view of X, Facebook, or TikTok to think of users as wandering spirits seeking each other in the shadows before finally uniting. But in essence, that’s what’s happening, on a much grander scale, just as it did with party-affiliated newspapers in the 1830s.

And scale matters.

“In democratic nations… it is always necessary that those associating must be very numerous in order that the association may have some power” De Toccqueville wrote.

When historians write about the “revolution” in communication and transportation, they are not overstating the case. Until the 1840s, time and distance restricted the ability of Americans to travel and communicate quickly with anyone more than a few dozen miles away.

The invention of the telegraph in 1844 and the rapid expansion of railroads – track mileage soared from 1,000 miles in 1835 to 3,000 miles in 1840 to 30,000 miles by 1860 – altered the landscape in ways de Tocqueville and few of his contemporaries could imagine.

The telegraph spread news almost instantaneously. Railroads carried ever more newspapers – from 900 in 1830 to 3,000 in 1860 – into every corner of the country. Suddenly what happened in New York or Washington could be read about within days in virtually every small town east of the Mississippi.

This resulted in a better-informed populace and provided greater opportunities for like-minded citizens to communicate and organize.

But it also began the process of nationalizing the media, a trend that continues today. The concentration of information resources in Washington and New York divorced large segments of the population from the unifying spirit of mass media, creating the need for a social media that gathers De Tocqueville’s “wandering spirits” in search of each other.

John Bicknell was a journalist for 30 years, as a reporter, editor, columnist, and opinion writer in Florida and Washington, D.C. He is the author of three books – America 1844: Religious Fervor, Westward Expansion and the Presidential Election That Transformed the Nation, Lincoln’s Pathfinder: John C. Fremont and the Violent Election of 1856, and The Pathfinder and the President: John C. Fremont, Abraham Lincoln, and the Battle for Emancipation –and was a senior editor of the 2016, 2018, 2020, and 2022 editions of The Almanac of America Politics.

Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.

Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.