Guest Essayist: James Robbins

Our Commissioners | Office of the Texas Governor | Greg Abbott
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner

 

​“I have a rendezvous with Death,” wrote American poet Alan Seeger in 1916, envisioning sacrifice with almost romantic nobility. Like many young men of his generation, Seeger believed that service and even death in a great cause could give meaning to life. Killed while serving with the French Foreign Legion before the United States entered the First World War, his words foreshadowed the spirit of the generation of writers that emerged afterward and revealed how profoundly those hopes had been shaken.

In April 1917, young Americans marched off to Europe with enthusiasm and a sense of purpose. President Woodrow Wilson had asked Congress for a declaration of war to make the world “safe for democracy,” and many believed that the conflict would be “the war to end war.” People were willing to face great sacrifices because they believed this would secure a better and more peaceful world. 

Yet by the 1920s, the veterans and writers who came to be known as the Lost Generation, a term coined by Gertrude Stein and popularized by Ernest Hemingway, looked back with profound disillusionment. Their dissatisfaction arose not merely from the horrors they had endured but from the belief that the ideals for which they had fought had been compromised or abandoned.

The first act of this tragedy was framed by idealism. Many Americans willingly assumed obligations to the nation because they believed in the justice of its cause. They entered the First World War with high hopes and lofty aspirations. President Wilson spoke in moral terms, promising a world made safe for democracy and a peace that would prevent future conflicts. Many citizens willingly placed their lives in jeopardy because they trusted that their leaders were pursuing objectives worthy of a free people.

The second act brought a harsh awakening. In the trenches and battlefields of France, industrial warfare inflicted death and destruction on a scale previously unknown. Machine guns, poison gas, devastating artillery barrages, and mass casualties shattered the romantic notions of glory and heroism that had been nurtured since the Civil War. American poet John Allan Wyeth, who served with the American Expeditionary Forces, captured the confusion, exhaustion, and irony of war in his sonnet sequence This Man’s Army: A War in Fifty-odd Sonnets. Other American writers who experienced the war firsthand included Ernest Hemingway and John Dos Passos, who both portrayed the deeply human tragedy of war. The men who endured bombardments and carried the wounded understood that patriotism and sacrifice were real, but so were shattered bodies and broken lives. 

These writers did not merely lament the cruelty of war. They exposed the gulf between the abstract rhetoric of policymakers and the terrible realities borne by ordinary soldiers. Hemingway would later write that words such as “glory” and “honor” seemed obscene compared to the suffering of war. Dos Passos observed that “war is utter damn nonsense, a vast cancer fed by lies and self-seeking malignity on the part of those who don’t do the fighting.” Their writings served as a reminder that governments must speak truthfully to citizens and that free peoples deserve honesty about the costs of military conflict.

Yet the most enduring emotional wounds came after the guns fell silent. This was the third act of the tragedy, the squandered victory. The Versailles peace agreement saw American idealism, as summed up in President Wilson’s “14 Points,” swept aside by European power, politics, and imperialism. The war to make the world safe for democracy gave rise first to Russian Bolshevism and later to Fascism and Nazism. And the “war to end all war” set the conditions for an even more destructive conflict erupting two decades later. Looking backward, many veterans concluded that the lofty promises that had justified so much suffering had been abandoned.

This is the necessary context for understanding the Lost Generation. Its members were not united by cynicism so much as by broken expectations. They had believed that their sacrifices would usher in a new age. Instead, they found a world that appeared to have learned little from catastrophe. Their dissatisfaction reflected not merely revulsion at war itself but disillusionment with the results achieved in its aftermath.

Veteran writers such as John Wyeth, Ernest Hemingway, and John Dos Passos expressed skepticism toward grand rhetoric and distrust toward leaders who spoke in exalted terms while failing to achieve the ends for which so many had suffered. Their message was a warning about the fragility of trust between the people and those who govern them.

The experience of the First World War thus offers an enduring lesson about popular consent. Governments may ask much of free citizens, even their lives, but they incur solemn obligations in return. Leaders must be truthful about the costs of war, prudent in their conduct, and faithful to the principles they invoke. Citizens may willingly bear extraordinary burdens when they believe those burdens serve noble purposes, but trust once broken is not easily restored.

The tragedy of the Lost Generation was not simply that young Americans encountered the horrors of war; it was that many came to believe that the ideals for which they had fought had been merely empty rhetoric. Their testimony reminds succeeding generations of the importance of nurturing the continuing trust and consent of the people. Preserving that trust is among the highest responsibilities of republican government. It requires wisdom, honesty, and fidelity to the purposes for which free people are asked to sacrifice.

 

Dr. James S. Robbins is Senior Vice President for Research and Business Development at the Institute of World Politics, and a Senior Fellow for National Security Affairs at the American Foreign Policy Council. A historian, educator, and commentator, he is the author of five books and more than 2,000 articles and columns on national security, foreign policy, and American history. He previously served as Senior Editorial Writer for The Washington Times and spent ten years in government as a counter-terrorism specialist. A frequent television and radio guest, he has taught and advised students, military officers, and policymakers for more than three decades.

 

Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.

Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.

Guest Essayist: James Robbins

Our Commissioners | Office of the Texas Governor | Greg Abbott
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner

The essays in our study reference the following edition of Democracy In America: University of Chicago Press – 1st edition translated by Harvey Mansfield and Delba Winthrop. Today’s essay references pages 617 (start at chapter 22 heading) – 625 of this edition of Democracy in America.

In Chapters 22 and 23 of Part 2 of Democracy in America, Alexis de Tocqueville addressed the proper role of military affairs in a democracy. In his time as today, the limits of military power in politics are an important concern. De Tocqueville was born during the rule of Napoleon Bonaparte, a General who had overthrown the French First Republic and made himself Emperor. When De Tocqueville was still a child, he saw Napoleon’s downfall and the restoration of a constitutional monarchy in France. His experience helped shape his views on how a democracy can be undermined by the ambitions of men in uniform.

In Chapter 22, De Tocqueville noted that democracies are generally interested in living at peace with their neighbors. He wrote that “amongst civilized nations, the warlike passions will become more rare and less intense in proportion as social conditions shall be more equal.” Ideas such as this would later evolve into concepts like the democratic peace theory, i.e., since democracies seldom go to war with each other, a more democratic world will necessarily be more stable and peaceful.
However, since “war is nevertheless an occurrence to which all nations are subject,” even peaceful democratic nations “must hold themselves in readiness to repel aggression” with some form of standing military force. This force can pose problems for democratic governments.

De Tocqueville writes that in some cases ambition among officers may create a desire to go to war to seek promotion through acts of valor. And while such wars may have advantages, they can also be dangerous. Wars can endanger freedom in democracies by increasing the power of government, and protracted wars in particular are a threat to maintaining liberty. “There are two things which a democratic people will always find very difficult,” De Tocqueville writes, “to begin a war, and to end it.”

In Chapter 23, De Tocqueville notes that these tendencies can be compounded by the character of democratic armies, which are fundamentally different from those in aristocracies. In aristocratic societies, with their firm class divisions, officers are typically drawn from the nobility, who have important interests in maintaining the status quo. In democracies, officers often come from the middle or lower classes, who may have more ambition to improve their station in life. This ambition makes them more likely to support revolutionary changes that could improve their opportunities and status. As noted above, this may mean support for war as a vehicle for achieving fame, honor, and promotion, things which can be elusive in peacetime.

The remedy for these challenges, De Tocqueville says, “is not to be found in the army itself, but in the country.” That is, the citizen-soldiers who make up the largest part of the military are also those who are most habituated to freedom, and who want to maintain it. “Upon them the habits of the nation have the firmest hold,” De Tocqueville writes. Through them “it may be possible to infuse into a democratic army the love of freedom and the respect of rights” which reflect the country as a whole.
The United States of the 1830s was less threatened than some European states by these power dynamics. De Tocqueville notes that America had the benefit of being removed from European affairs, bounded by vast oceans and having (with some exceptions) generally peaceful relations with its neighbors. This meant that the United States did not require a vast standing army to secure its borders. Only a small regular force was needed, and in time of emergency the county could quickly mobilize the type of citizen militias that were most sympathetic to maintaining freedom.

Like De Tocqueville, the Founding Fathers were also concerned about the potential threat from a large standing military. In the Constitution they provided a variety of checks and balances on military power to keep control firmly in civilian hands. This included making the President the Commander in Chief of the armed forces, giving Congress control over military appropriations, and also reserving to Congress the power to declare war.
There was also the example of George Washington, who represented the ideal of the American citizen-soldier. He had left his farm at Mt. Vernon to take command of the Continental Army during the American Revolution, after which he returned to civilian life, and later to the presidency. Washington set an example of service and conduct for an American officer, who was expected to be professional, capable, and apolitical. This ethos became a guiding spirit in the American military that has persisted to the current day.

De Tocqueville’s analysis of civil-military relations in a democracy continues to offer valuable perspectives on the interplay between politics, military service, and social mobility. While the United States has been able to maintain its democratic character even with the vast growth of its military and responsibilities for global leadership, the corrosive power dynamics that De Tocqueville wrote about remain a challenge to free countries. Constant vigilance is required to ensure that the forces needed to defend freedom do not become the means to undermine and destroy it.

 

Dr. Robbins is a former special assistant in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, and in 2007 was awarded the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Joint Meritorious Civilian Service Award.

He is also the former award-winning Senior Editorial Writer for Foreign Affairs at The Washington Times. His work has also appeared in The Wall Street Journal, National Review, and other publications. He appears regularly on national and international television and radio.

Dr. Robbins holds a Ph.D. from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy and has taught at the National Defense University and Marine Corps University, among other schools. His research interests include terrorism and national security strategy, political theory and military history.

Dr. Robbins is the author of five books, including The Real Custer: From Boy General to Tragic Hero, This Time We Win: Revisiting the Tet Offensive, and the critically acclaimed Last in Their Class: Custer, Pickett and the Goats of West Point.

Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.

Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.