
Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner
The essays in our study reference the following edition of Democracy In America: University of Chicago Press – 1st edition translated by Harvey Mansfield and Delba Winthrop. Today’s essay references pages 640 (start at chapter 2 heading) – 643 (stop at chapter 3 heading) of this edition of Democracy in America.
In 1831, twenty-six year old Alexis de Tocqueville found the United States to be a nation of 13,000,000 inhabitants, experiencing the early years of the Age of Jackson. As he surveyed the democratic character of America taking root in a land of considerable natural wealth, the young Frenchman reached several conclusions about democratic peoples and their government.
Coordination of power and authority should be exercised by competent, trustworthy, and confident leadership. De Tocqueville explains his belief that such efficiency will create an effective government “in which all the citizens resemble a single model and are directed by a single power” (640). The government will be lean and well-disciplined, with unity among its people. Slothful bureaucracy will be resisted in favor of responsive action.
At the core of such a democratic model, however, is the requirement that government must wield its authority equally and fairly, impacting everyone without partiality or bias. De Tocqueville warns that “unfair rule equally imposed on all members of the social body is foreign…to the human mind in aristocratic centuries. It does not receive it or it rejects it” (641). Thus, concentrated governmental power must not be dictatorial or laced with favoritism. Rather, “its duty as well as its right is to take each citizen by the hand and lead him”(641). Trust is essential.
Democratic peoples deserve governments which display this adherence to fairness and objectivity. Patience and uniformity in the exercise of power are necessary because “governments exhaust themselves to impose the same usages and the same laws on populations that do not yet resemble each other” (641). Among democratic peoples, De Tocqueville suggests, “privileges of society” (641) overshadow individuals, who become “lost in the crowd” (641). Common goals, society’s goals, are supreme because they strengthen everyone and promote collegiality.
Democratic peoples adhere to and accept their governments’ mandates because there is a widespread realization that the people, ultimately, remain supreme, willfully endorsing and accepting displays of power by governments. De Tocqueville notes, “all conceive the government in the image of a lone, simple, providential, and creative power” (642). Positive results are produced by this arrangement because it yields tangible energy, efficiency, fairness, and allegiance to democracy’s tenets. Our French visitor stresses that “the government and those governing are in accord in pursuing it with the same ardor; it comes first, it seems innate” (642). A partnership, favorable to all, is established among the democratic peoples and their governments.
This power partnership operates well because the people realize and accept that concentration of power in governmental hands strengthens society. Security, responsiveness, sensible use of resources, progress, and adherence to democracy become inter-related by such a beneficial arrangement. Our visitor concluded optimistically that this sleek governmental model “is a natural condition of the current state of men” (642). It displays long term benefits for both government and the governed.
Dr. Edward Lee is a 40 year veteran of the university classroom. He has won several awards for his exemplary teaching, including a Presidential Citation in 1996 for his pioneer work with distance education. He is the author or co-author of 21 books, including 4 about America and the conflict in Vietnam. His commentary has appeared on Fox News, CNN, NBC News, and National Public Radio.
Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.
Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.




Edward Lee, Ph.D., is Professor of History at Winthrop University. Lee is a former mayor of the City of York, South Carolina.
Podcast by Maureen Quinn.

