Essay 6-B: James Madison, George Mason, and the Ratification Debate Over The Constitution

Essay Read by Constituting America Founder, Actress Janine Turner

In the summer of 1787, leaders from across the United States gathered in Philadelphia for the stated purpose of fixing flaws in the Articles of Confederation. But in the minds of nationalists like James Madison, fixing issues with the Articles was not the answer. What was needed was an entirely new form of government that could allow the fledgling nation to grow. This convention, known at the time as the Philadelphia or Federal Convention was largely organized by Madison, Alexander Hamilton, and the government created at that gathering bore Madison’s indelible stamp.

To give the gathering the credibility it needed to make significant changes to the government, Madison and Hamilton recognized the importance of having both Benjamin Franklin and George Washington in attendance, thus implying their tacit approval. Franklin, despite his age (he was 81) and constant issues with gout, happily attended, telling his friend Benjamin Rush that the convention was “the most august and respectable assembly he was ever in in his life.” And, after much consideration and numerous letters and visits from Madison, Washington also agreed to attend. In a sign of the importance Madison placed on this convention, he assigned himself the task of taking detailed notes each day and refining them each night, leaving to posterity the most complete record of the convention.

In terms of the debate, the single most critical issue to be resolved was how representation in Congress would be determined, for with more representatives came more power. Madison believed that all representation should be based on population, not surprising given his home state of Virginia was the most populous state in the country. And to that end, when Edmund Randolph, Governor of Virginia, proposed his Virginia Plan, fifteen resolutions that were essentially Madison’s concept for the new government, the basis of the plan called for representation according to population in both chambers of Congress. But smaller states had little desire to join a national union that diminished their influence. As such, William Patterson of New Jersey put forth what has come to be known as the New Jersey Plan, which called for equal representation in Congress for each state. Madison was at the center of this heated debate, without question the most intense of the entire convention, and his grasp of constitutional law and structure impressed all delegates. William Pierce of Georgia stated that of “the affairs of the United States, he (Madison) perhaps, had the most correct knowledge of any man in the Union.”

From these two conflicting plans, Roger Sherman crafted the Great or Connecticut Compromise which called for representation in the lower chamber (the House of Representatives) to be proportional according to population, but for all states to have equal representation in the upper chamber (the Senate). Madison strongly opposed this compromise, but ultimately, Sherman’s proposal was adopted by a single vote. Despite this defeat and the disappointment felt by Madison and Washington, this compromise was a win for the nation as it prevented a premature end to the convention. As Madison later stated, “The threatening contest in the convention of 1787 did not, as you supposed, turn on the degree of power to be granted to the federal government, but on the rule by which the states should be represented and vote in government.”

And after the adoption of the Great Compromise, everything got easier; every issue was more easily overcome, and other compromises were more easily found. Madison later wrote that, “from the day when every doubt of the right of the smaller states to an equal vote in the Senate was quieted, they…exceeded all others in zeal for granting power to the general government.” The smaller states recognized that a country unified behind a strong central government offered them a degree of protection that they could never achieve on their own. Ultimately, the Constitution was signed on September 17, 1787, by thirty-nine delegates representing twelve states (Rhode Island did not send a delegation). But that passage was only the first step in the adoption process. The next step, perhaps the most important, was getting the states to approve the Constitution at their separate ratifying conventions.

To help convince skeptical Americans of the merits of the new Constitution, Madison, Hamilton and John Jay, in the fall of 1787, drafted a series of articles that have come to be known as The Federalist Papers. This series of eighty-five essays, arguably the greatest collection of writings ever on a federal constitutional government, laid out for the American public the argument for the adoption of the new constitution. Hamilton took the lead on these essays, writing fifty-one of them, while Madison drafted twenty- nine and Jay five (poor health limited Jay’s participation). While Madison’s contribution quantitatively was less than Hamilton’s; two of Madison’s essays are among the most prominent of the series. Federalist #10 argues that the sort of representative democracy proposed by the Constitution was the greatest safeguard against the excesses of partisanship and factionalism, while Federalist #51 explains the need for a series of checks and balances between the three branches of government (legislative, executive, judicial) to hold those who govern in check, with Madison famously writing, “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”

Across the nation, eyes turned toward Virginia to see what direction that state would go, as many prominent Virginians including Patrick Henry and George Mason were known to oppose the proposed Constitution. All understood that without Virginia’s approval, the Constitution could not be implemented. At the Virginia ratifying convention in June 1788, countering Henry’s great oratory with precise, logical arguments on the benefits of the Constitution, Madison carried the day, and the constitutionalists ultimately prevailed.

Thus, at every step in the constitutional process, James Madison took the lead. Madison organized the Constitutional convention, drafted the basic outline of the Constitution, recorded the proceedings for posterity, wrote many of the essays that swayed his fellow citizens, and was instrumental in convincing Virginians to adopt the new law of the land. No other Founding Father played such an outsized role in creating our nation’s Constitution.

Tom Hand created Americana Corner in 2020 to share informative stories of the momentous events, significant documents and influential leaders that helped create and shape our country. Through compelling articles and captivating videos, Tom hopes to rekindle a spirit of patriotism in his fellow Americans, and remind them of our nation’s incredible past and why our founding era still matters today.

He is the author of a growing series of books that reflect his deep commitment to early American History:
An American Triumph: America’s Founding Era through the Lives of Ben Franklin, George Washington, and John Adams –– an engaging narrative that blends the personal experiences and historic milestones of three Founding Fathers enriched by 130 images and a dozen detailed maps.

America Victorious: Lesser-Known Campaigns and Commanders That Helped Win American Independence –– a companion volume that highlights the lesser-known heroes who fought for our nation’s independence across countless battlefields in the early republic.

Tom’s passion for telling the Great American Story extends to preserving its cultural and historical treasures through the Preserving America program. This nationwide initiative supports a diverse range of projects through grants, fosters long-term partnerships with historical organizations, and hosts an annual conference that brings together leaders in preservation and public history to share best practices, exchange ideas, and inspire collaboration.

A graduate of the United States Military Academy at West Point (Class of 1982), Tom went on to create the Gilman Cheese Corporation after leaving the military. Now retired from business, Tom devotes his time to Americana Corner and serves on the Board of Trustees for the American Battlefield Trust. He has the good fortune to be married to his best friend, Char, who reviews all his work and provides unending support. He enjoys reading books on American history, classic novels, and playing his guitar.

Click here to receive our Daily 90-Day Study Essay emailed directly to your inbox.

Click here for the essay schedule with today’s essay and previously published essays hyperlinked.

PRINT ARTICLE